This post isn’t just a rant — though there will be ranting. It’s a spoiler for every team that’s ever said: “Let’s just do a quick design audit” with the same energy as someone saying “I’ll just Google the symptoms.”
So, you’re staring down sluggish conversion numbers, vague user complaints, or an executive Slack message saying: “The product feels… off.”
Suddenly, someone suggests the magic cure-all: the ‘quick design audit.’ It sounds practical. Low-lift. Almost responsible. It rarely is.
Here’s the usual setup:
The product’s live. Things are kind of working.
But conversions are sluggish.
Users are confused.
Feedback is inconsistent.
So someone (usually in marketing or product) floats the magic phrase:
“Let’s do a quick design audit — just to check for obvious stuff.”
By “obvious,” they mean: spacing inconsistencies, button colours, maybe a weird font size here and there.
By “quick,” they mean “can you do it by Thursday.”
WHAT THEY EXPECT: A neat little report. A tidy list of UI tweaks. Maybe some “low-hanging fruit.” Something they can forward in an email thread with the subject line: ‘Insights!’
WHAT THEY GET (if it’s done right): A full-blown intervention. Not a vibe check. A product-wide reality check. And it rarely fits in a tidy PDF.
What a Real Design Audit Involves
A proper design audit isn’t about judging your typography alignment from a pedestal. It’s about exposing where your product’s design is lying to you. Where it pretends to be working — but isn’t. Where it’s alienating users, hiding conversions, or silently killing trust.
Here’s what actually goes into a real website design audit or UX design audit:
- Mapping user flows and seeing where they break
- Heuristics + accessibility checks
- Reviewing visual hierarchy vs. user goals
- Analysing onboarding, empty states, error states (aka the stuff you forgot)
- Real content review (no more lorem ipsum lies)
- Testing for mobile/device weirdness
- Benchmarking against UX best practices (but not worshipping them)
It’s more surgery than skincare. And yes, it takes time.
The audit isn’t about polishing what you have — it’s about deciding what doesn’t belong.
The Misconceptions That Never Die
We just need a quick once-over!
Nope. That’s called a vibe check. A design audit report is meant to reveal systemic issues — and that means going deep, not wide.
_
It’s just visual stuff, right?
Wrong again. Most of the time, your visual issues are symptoms, not causes. Misaligned visuals often point to misaligned strategy. Or worse — zero strategy.
_
We’ll fix it all in Phase 2
Spoiler: There is no Phase 2. If you don’t act on audit insights quickly, they become a graveyard of forgotten Notion comments.
(Bonus myth: “We already have a design system.” Doesn’t matter. Most audits reveal it’s either not used, not followed, or quietly despised by your team.)
What a Design Audit Actually Uncovers
Think your web design audit will just find a few font mismatches? Think again. Here’s what we’ve actually uncovered during real audits:
- A signup flow that looked sleek but buried key CTAs below the fold
- A dashboard designed by committee with six conflicting hierarchies
- Buttons that passed contrast checks — but failed common sense
- Copy that sounded smart in marketing but made zero sense to users
- A design system full of components that no one actually used
And one memorable gem: a product where clicking the main CTA triggered two modals — at once. One for login, one for newsletter signup. Choose your adventure.
Most of all? A lack of narrative. No clear user journey. No hierarchy of needs. Just a soup of features and styles hoping users would “figure it out.”
If You’re Gonna Ask for One, Be Ready
If your team is considering a website design audit, understand what you’re signing up for:
- You’ll need to let your ego take a backseat. A good audit will hurt (a little :).
- You’ll need to give access to actual data and real user flows — not just pretty screenshots.
- You’ll need to act on the findings. Or at least prioritise them.
An audit with no follow-through is just an expensive to-do list you’ll ignore in three weeks.
You don’t need a design audit just to make your interface “nicer.” You need it to make sure your product isn’t confusing, frustrating, or quietly driving people away.
Don’t Treat Audits Like Tickboxes
Great design audits aren’t just about compliance or polish. They’re about clarity. Direction. Progress.
They won’t give you a list of fonts to fix. They’ll show you what your users are silently screaming every time they bounce.
So next time you hear someone say, “Let’s do a quick design audit,” just smile and nod. Then tell them you’ll need three weeks, access to everything, and 10 strong cups of coffee per day.
Because good design isn’t just what it looks like. It’s what happens when no one’s watching.